• Mother's Day Sale 20% Off | Site-Wide | Use Coupon Code "GIFTMOM20" at Checkout
  • Proudly Made in USA   usa flag
  • Buy Now, Pay Later
Fascinating Diamonds

Gemstone Engagement Rings for Women

The woman of your dreams deserves a unique declaration of love and commitment—and our gemstone engagement rings do exactly that. Handcrafted by expert craftsmen and customizable with natural or lab-grown diamonds, every ring honors your unique story. Find the one that will take her breath away!

          Explore Our Gemstone Engagement Rings Collection


round-sapphire-and-diamond-flower-engagement-ring-in-FD10057RORGSABLANGLE3-NL-WG-GS
Fascinating Diamond
round-sapphire-and-diamond-flower-engagement-ring-in-FD10057RORGSABLANGLE3-NL-WG-GS
Fascinating Diamond

0.50 Ct Round Flower Gemstone Engagement Ring

$1,532.95
+4
+2
horizontal-marquise-sapphire-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-fdenr11664mqgsablsleep-nl-rg
Fascinating Diamond
horizontal-marquise-sapphire-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-fdenr11664mqgsablsleep-nl-rg
Fascinating Diamond

Gemstone East West Marquise Solitaire Ring

$1,553.65
+4
+2
Fascinating Diamond
Celtic Knot Split Pear Ruby Wedding Ring Set
Fascinating Diamond

Celtic Knot Split Pear Ruby Wedding Ring Set

$2,489.75
+4
+1
celtic-knot-pear-shaped-ruby-ring-in-yellow-gold-fdens9609pergrudrsleep-nl-yg?v=1756204380
Fascinating Diamond
celtic-knot-pear-shaped-ruby-ring-in-yellow-gold-fdens9609pergrudrsleep-nl-yg?v=1756204380
Fascinating Diamond

Celtic Knot Pear Shaped Colored Ring

$1,689.35
+4
+1
emerald-cut-sapphire-single-prong-diamond-bridal-rings-set-in-FDENS3023EMGSABL-NL-RG-GS
Fascinating Diamond
emerald-cut-emerald-single-prong-diamond-bridal-rings-set-in-FDENS3023EMGEMGR-NL-RG-GS
Fascinating Diamond

Gemstone Single Prong Bridal Ring Set

$2,892.25
+4
+1
diamond-leaf-square-antique-diamond-ring-in-FD10044RANGLE3-NL-YG-GS
Fascinating Diamond
pink-sapphire-leaf-square-antique-diamond-ring-in-FD10044RGSADRPIANGLE3-NL-YG-GS
Fascinating Diamond

Leaf Cushion Cut Gemstone Vintage Engagement Ring

$2,121.75
+4
+2
underhalo-princess-cut-pink-sapphire-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-FD9168PRRGSADRPI-NL-RG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
underhalo-princess-cut-pink-sapphire-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-FD9168PRRGSADRPI-NL-RG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Under Halo Princess Cut Gemstone And Diamond Ring

$1,670.95
+4
+1
oval-halo-ruby-milgrain-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-FD9786OVRGRUDR-NL-RG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
oval-halo-ruby-milgrain-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-FD9786OVRGRUDR-NL-RG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Oval Halo Gemstone Milgrain Engagement Ring

$2,260.90
+4
+2
oval-ruby-3-stone-engagement-ring-in-yellow-gold-FDENR1505OVRGRD-NL-YG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
oval-ruby-3-stone-engagement-ring-in-yellow-gold-FDENR1505OVRGRD-NL-YG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Gemstone Classic 3 Stone Ring

$2,358.65
+4
+2
antique-round-emerald-ring-in-rose-gold-FD67850RORGEMGR-NL-RG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
antique-round-emerald-ring-in-rose-gold-FD67850RORGEMGR-NL-RG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Antique Round Gemstone Rings

$1,150.00
+4
+3
beautiful-crossover-round-ruby-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-FDENS3007RORGRUDR-NL-RG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
beautiful-crossover-round-ruby-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-FDENS3007RORGRUDR-NL-RG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Beautiful Crossover Gemstone Ring

$1,428.30
+4
+2
beautiful-crossover-round-ruby-wedding-set-in-rose-gold-FDENS3007ROGRUDR-NL-RG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
beautiful-crossover-round-ruby-wedding-set-in-rose-gold-FDENS3007ROGRUDR-NL-RG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Beautiful Crossover Gemstone Wedding Set

$2,408.10
+4
+2
alternate-ruby-3-stone-engagement-ring-in-white-gold-FD9006EMGRUDR-NL-WG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
alternate-ruby-3-stone-engagement-ring-in-white-gold-FD9006EMGRUDR-NL-WG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Alternate Gemstone 3 Stone Ring

$1,323.65
+4
+3
ruby-heart-cluster-diamond-wedding-ring-set-in-yellow-gold-FDENS3110HTGRUDR-NL-YG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
ruby-heart-cluster-diamond-wedding-ring-set-in-yellow-gold-FDENS3110HTGRUDR-NL-YG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Colored Heart Cluster Diamond Wedding Set

$2,630.05
+4
+2
unique-pear-cluster-bezel-sapphire-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-FDENS3110PERGSABL-NL-RG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
unique-pear-cluster-bezel-sapphire-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-FDENS3110PERGSABL-NL-RG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Unique Pear Cluster Bezel Engagement Ring

$1,830.80
+4
round-rope-ruby-engagement-ring-in-white-gold-FD9127RORGRD-NL-WG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
round-rope-ruby-engagement-ring-in-white-gold-FD9127RORGRD-NL-WG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Round Rope Gemstone Engagement Ring

$1,822.75
+4
+3
hidden-halo-round-sapphire-engagement-ring-with-diamond-in-rose-gold-FD11370RORGSABL-NL-RG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
hidden-halo-round-sapphire-engagement-ring-with-diamond-in-rose-gold-FD11370RORGSABL-NL-RG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Hidden Halo Round Gemstone Engagement Ring

$2,812.90
+4
+1
oval-petite-cathedral-emerald-ring-in-white-gold-FD9275OVR-NL-WG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
oval-petite-cathedral-emerald-ring-in-white-gold-FD9275OVR-NL-WG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Oval Petite Cathedral Gemstone Ring

$2,065.40
+4
unusual-sapphire-bezel-set-engagement-ring-in-yellow-gold-FD72035RORGBS-NL-YG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
unusual-sapphire-bezel-set-engagement-ring-in-yellow-gold-FD72035RORGBS-NL-YG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Unusual Gemstone Bezel Set Engagement Ring

$1,789.40
+1
+5
non-traditional-ruby-ring-in-rose-gold-FD9007PRGRUDR-NL-RG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
non-traditional-ruby-ring-in-rose-gold-FD9007PRGRUDR-NL-RG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Non Traditional Gemstone Ring

$1,214.40
+4
+2
unconventional-ruby-engagement-ring-for-women-in-yellow-gold-FD9008EMGRUDR-NL-YG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
unconventional-ruby-engagement-ring-for-women-in-yellow-gold-FD9008EMGRUDR-NL-YG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Unconventional Gemstone Ring For Women

$1,229.35
+4
+3
oval-emerald-halo-cathedral-ring-in-rose-gold-FD10561OVGEMGR-NL-RG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
oval-emerald-halo-cathedral-ring-in-rose-gold-FD10561OVGEMGR-NL-RG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Oval Gemstone Halo Cathedral Ring

$2,988.85
+4
+3
round-cut-pink-sapphire-halo-swirl-split-diamond-engagement-ring-in-yellow-gold-FD11180RORGSADRPI-NL-YG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
round-cut-pink-sapphire-halo-swirl-split-diamond-engagement-ring-in-yellow-gold-FD11180RORGSADRPI-NL-YG-GS.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Round Gemstone Halo Swirl Split Ring

$1,979.15
+4
+2
colored-emerald-cut-halo-diamond-engagement-ring-with-ruby-in-rose-gold-FD9710EMRGRUDR-NL-RG-B1-GS - Copy.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
colored-emerald-cut-halo-diamond-engagement-ring-with-ruby-in-rose-gold-FD9710EMRGRUDR-NL-RG-B1-GS - Copy.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Gemstone Halo Diamond Engagement Ring

$1,844.60
+4
+1
split-shank-emerald-emerald-cut-diamond-halo-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-FD9608EMRGEMGR-NL-RG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond
split-shank-emerald-emerald-cut-diamond-halo-engagement-ring-in-rose-gold-FD9608EMRGEMGR-NL-RG.jpg
Fascinating Diamond

Split Shank Emerald Cut Gemstone Engagement Ring

$2,096.45
+4
+1
nature-inspired-petite-vine-princess-cut-pink-sapphire-ring-in-white-gold-FD8233PRRGSADRPI-NL-WG-GS
Fascinating Diamond
nature-inspired-petite-vine-princess-cut-pink-sapphire-ring-in-white-gold-FD8233PRRGSADRPI-NL-WG-GS
Fascinating Diamond

Princess Cut Gemstone Infinity Twist Ring

$1,937.75
+4
+1
round-cut-vine-motif-gemstone-ring-in-white-gold-FD8253RORGBS-NL-WG
Fascinating Diamond
round-cut-vine-motif-gemstone-ring-in-white-gold-FD8253RORGBS-NL-WG
Fascinating Diamond

Petite Twisted Engagement Ring Colored Stones

$2,193.05
+4
+2
3-stone-oval-bezel-emerald-engagement-ring-in-yellow-gold-fd11546gemgr-nl-yg
Fascinating Diamond
3-stone-oval-bezel-emerald-engagement-ring-in-yellow-gold-fd11546gemgr-nl-yg
Fascinating Diamond

3 Stone Oval Bezel Gemstone Engagement Ring

$2,117.15
+4
+2
half-bezel-oval-shaped-sapphire-east-west-ring-in-rose-gold-fd11531ovrgsabl-nl-rg
Fascinating Diamond
half-bezel-oval-shaped-sapphire-east-west-ring-in-rose-gold-fd11531ovrgsabl-nl-rg
Fascinating Diamond

Half Bezel Oval East West Colored Ring

$3,136.05
+4
+2

Why Customers Love Fascinating Diamonds

  • Tim C

    Tim Calandrello

    ★★★★★

    I was extremely happy with my entire experience and the jewelry is gorgeous. There was also really great communication with the company when I had questions. They were professional, responsive and a pleasure to deal with. The item arrived exactly when they said it would and I couldn't be happier. I'll absolutely order from them again.

  • Bri

    Bri

    ★★★★★
    Beautiful, Excellent Communication

    Excellent, quick, effective communication. The ring I picked out came out even more beautiful than I expected.

  • Kevin M.

    Kevin M.

    ★★★★★
    As always, Raj has given perfect

    As always,Raj has given perfect product and service. I'm a customer for life

  • Caroline W

    Caroline Wooldridge

    ★★★★★

    Raj was very communicative, empathetic and proactive in trying to help me with my mother's birthday gift. Would recommend! FYI, Im not a big jewelry buyer so was unfamiliar with these kind of stores/offices, but it's like a small office on high floor. He has a variety of samples/examples there, but most are ordered / custom (vs a full retail store.)

  • Linda C

    Linda Courtney

    ★★★★★
    The ring I received is lovely

    The ring I received is lovely! There was an error to my order and they adjusted the difference promptly to my account. I would highly recommend this company!

  • Cynthia T.

    Cynthia T.

    ★★★★★
    Will definitely buy from again.

    Will definitely buy from again. Beautiful product, great communication, secure shipping.

  • Kevin Mcknight

    Kevin Mcknight

    ★★★★★

    I received the very best customer service ever!!!! Raj was absolutely awesome. The diamond ring we purchased is beautiful and very well made. I will be a return client for many years and occasions. Just the best retail experience online!!!!

  • FB

    FB

    ★★★★★
    Great Purchase

    Beautiful earrings and setting. Kind people that are always willing to answer questions.

  • Mirander

    Mirander

    ★★★★★
    good

    remarkable pendant with exquisite design. I am in love....thank you

Gemstone Engagement Rings

Discover gemstone engagement rings featuring sapphire, emerald, ruby, and black diamond center stones. Designed for durability, symbolism, and standout color, these rings are ideal for couples seeking a meaningful alternative to traditional diamond engagement rings.

Our collection includes classic solitaires, halo styles, three-stone designs, and modern settings crafted in platinum, white gold, yellow gold, and rose gold. Each gemstone engagement ring is made to balance beauty with everyday wearability.

Read More

Sapphire Engagement Rings

Sapphire engagement rings are one of the most popular gemstone engagement ring choices due to their durability and deep, rich color. Ranking 9 on the Mohs hardness scale, sapphires are suitable for daily wear and offer long-term performance comparable to diamonds.

Available in classic blue as well as lighter and darker shades, sapphire engagement rings work well in solitaire, halo, and three-stone settings. They are often chosen by buyers looking for a gemstone that offers color, strength, and strong resale value.

Sapphire engagement rings are an excellent option for those who want a gemstone ring that balances beauty, durability, and timeless appeal.

Emerald Engagement Rings

Emerald engagement rings are known for their vibrant green color and unmistakable presence. Emeralds rank 7.5–8 on the Mohs scale, making them suitable for engagement rings when set properly with protective designs such as bezels or halos.

These gemstone engagement rings are ideal for buyers who value color intensity and symbolism. Emerald engagement rings pair especially well with step-cut or halo settings that enhance color depth while offering additional protection.

Emeralds require more care than sapphires or diamonds, making them best suited for buyers comfortable with mindful daily wear.

Ruby Engagement Rings

Ruby engagement rings feature a bold red gemstone that symbolizes commitment and strength. With a Mohs hardness of 9, rubies are among the most durable gemstones used in engagement rings.

This durability makes ruby engagement rings a practical choice for everyday wear. Rubies perform exceptionally well in solitaires, vintage-inspired designs, and halo settings that enhance brilliance and finger coverage.

Ruby engagement rings are often chosen by buyers seeking a distinctive gemstone that combines durability with strong visual impact.

Black Diamond Engagement Rings

Black diamond engagement rings offer a modern alternative for buyers looking for a bold, unconventional center stone. Black diamonds are real diamonds, treated or natural, with a hardness of 10, making them suitable for daily wear.

These gemstone engagement rings are commonly set in solitaire or accented styles using white diamonds for contrast. Black diamond engagement rings are popular among buyers who prefer contemporary design and a strong, graphic look.

Their durability and unique appearance make black diamond engagement rings a standout option within colored gemstone engagement rings.

Gemstone Engagement Rings vs Diamond Engagement Rings

Gemstone engagement rings offer a distinct alternative to traditional diamond rings. While diamonds remain the hardest gemstone, sapphires and rubies provide excellent durability with added color and symbolism.

Gemstone engagement rings often cost less than diamond engagement rings of similar size, allowing buyers to choose a larger center stone or more intricate setting without increasing budget. For those seeking individuality and meaning, gemstone engagement rings provide both value and visual distinction.

How to Choose the Right Gemstone for an Engagement Ring

When selecting a gemstone engagement ring, consider:

  • Durability: Sapphire, ruby, and black diamond are best for daily wear
  • Color preference: Choose a gemstone that reflects personal style
  • Setting type: Protective settings improve longevity for softer gemstones
  • Lifestyle: Active lifestyles benefit from harder gemstones

Choosing the right gemstone ensures long-term satisfaction and performance.

Customization & Craftsmanship

Our gemstone engagement rings are available in multiple metal options and settings. Each ring is crafted to ensure proper stone security, comfort, and durability. Select from platinum, white gold, yellow gold, or rose gold, with customization options available for center diamond shape and size.

FAQs For Gemstone Engagement Rings for Women

Are gemstone engagement rings durable enough for everyday wear?

Yes. Sapphire, ruby, and black diamond engagement rings are suitable for daily wear due to their high hardness. Emerald engagement rings require slightly more care.

Which gemstone is best for an engagement ring?

Sapphires and rubies are considered the best gemstones for engagement rings due to their durability, color stability, and long-term performance.

Are sapphire engagement rings more durable than emerald engagement rings?

Yes. Sapphire engagement rings rank higher on the Mohs scale and are more resistant to scratches than emerald engagement rings.

Do gemstone engagement rings cost less than diamond engagement rings?

In most cases, gemstone engagement rings cost less than diamond rings of similar size, allowing for better value or larger center stones.

Are black diamond engagement rings real diamonds?

Yes. Black diamond engagement rings use real diamonds that are either naturally black or treated to achieve their color.

How should I care for gemstone engagement rings?

Clean gemstone engagement rings with mild soap and warm water. Avoid harsh chemicals, and store rings separately to prevent scratching.

Show More

Terms & Conditions

Fascinating Diamonds supplies products listed on the Fascinating Diamonds, and Fascinating Diamonds websites, and in our stores under the following Terms and Conditions. Please read these Terms and Conditions, and our Privacy and Cookie Policies carefully before using any of our websites, or ordering from us.

The Terms and Conditions apply to your use of any Fascinating Diamonds website and to any products you purchase from them; regardless of how you access the website, including any technologies or devices where our website is available to you at home, on the move or in store

We reserve the right to update these Terms and Conditions at any time, and any updates affecting you or your purchases will be notified to you, by us in writing (via email), and on this page.

The headings in these Conditions are for convenience only and shall not affect their interpretation.

We recommend that you print and keep a copy of these Terms and Conditions for your future reference...